Reading
has many factors. First, reading is a visual process. It is the ability to see
symbols clearly with the eyes. It is a perceptual process-perception meaning that
our thought processes are able to take these symbols and to invest them with meaning.
It is an experiential process, because without experience there can be no perception,
for without experience the mind will be unable to invest meaning to the symbols
that we see. Reading comes about when we take meaning to the printed page, not
just the act of taking meaning from the printed page.
We often expect our students to be able to read and to gain meaning and knowledge
directly from the page or book without background, without experience, without
further information, without ever having been given the background knowledge about
the information that he is expected to learn. A student cannot learn from his
text without any experience beyond the page of print. This is a virtual impossibility.
He must have experiences which surround it. For example, it would bean impossibility
to learn chemistry from simply reading a book. One may learn possibly something
about it; but one could not really learn chemistry, about the formulas, about
acids, about the catalysing substances-without some knowledge other than a reading
knowledge of it. One has to see them, smell them, handle them, know them by actually
working with them. One may say that one can secure good grades even after learning
by the book only. But this is probably because of the poor examination that was
given, for it may have tested just his rote memory. Giving back ideas on an examination
might have been a totally factual situation, completely devoid of any real learning.
What
is Learning?
Learning
means that there is a change in behaviour through experience. Reading in this
case is the experience, and there can be a change of behaviour only if there has
been other things that go along with the reading. Suppose a person mixed a chemical
substance to make a formula but his only experience to this point is by reading.
He will therefore not know the chemicals by sight, by smell, and what happens
to them when the other things in the formula are added. Unless he knows about
these facts by actually handling them by himself he cannot be sure about the formula
he makes. Even if something goes wrong he will not know whether it is wrong if
he has only a book-knowledge and no actual experience outside the books. In other
words, reading must have an experimental factor. Reading must have experiences
tried in and related to it.
Vision
and Reading
Vision in reading and perception in reading
Here we will
discuss the function of each subsystem and indicate how each of these areas works
together for final conscious vision.
In this discussion of vision we will
be covering the following three aspects:
1. The Sensory mechanism
2. The
Motor mechanism-a binocular coordinating mechanism.
3. The Mental process
which produces a conscious organizational patterning of this process into what
we call visual perception.
First,
we will discuss the basic mechanical equipment that initiates the act of seeing.
The first of these is the two eye-balls, weighing only an ounce a piece. This
ocular equipment does the fantastic job of seeing for us. This eye-ball has a
lens, a shutter device, and internal fluid that aids focusing light waves. The
shutter device is that part of the eye we usually think of as brown (or blue,
for many Europeans). The black dot in the centre surrounded by the brown (or blue)
ring is the window or lens into the internal part of the eye. Through this black
dot light rays pass to the back of the eye. Finally there is a nerve sensitive
area or retina at the back of the eye to which the light rays are focused. The
light rays enter the eye, they are modified and adjusted by the fluid in the eye-ball
to hit directly at a point of focus at the very back of the eye. The point to
which it is focused is called the Fovea. The eye-balls make up the optic or refractive
system.
The second system is the binocular coordinating system. The eyes are not fixed
in a single permanent position, but they are free to move in their sockets through
a wide angle. There is a set of muscles that performs this task of movement as
well as another set that makes fine adjustments within the eye itself. There are
six muscles that move or steer the eye towards the object at which it wishes to
look. Any misalignment or maladjustment of those muscles will cause one eye to
look at a slightly different point of reference than does the other eye. Then
the person will either not see at all or he will see double. This problem of muscular
imbalance, as it is called, or lateral or vertical forea does have some relationship
to reading difficulty. If one is a slow reader and finds it difficult to learn
to read rapidly even under training it is not impossible that he has a visual
problem and that problem is muscular imbalance which causes the eyes to steer
rather poorly, one eye being slightly out of alignment with the other eye.
There are two more sets of muscles. They are the intrinsic muscles and the ciliary
muscles. They do the very delicate job of adjusting within the eye. One set of
muscles adjust for light conditions just like a camera would-it opens or closes
the curtain of the eye. The other set of muscles inside the eye adjusts the shape
of the lens in terms of depth of field or the distance at which one is looking.
When one is looking at a distance, the eye is slightly different in shape than
when one looks at something rather close up. The whole idea is that there must
be a sharp point of focus on the retina at all times. So these muscles work together
to lighten or darken in relation to the amount of light which is falling on the
retina while the other set of muscles adjust the shape of the eye so that there
is always a constant point of sharpness on the retina. As one gets older, these
muscles get weaker and they a little rigid. And thus the ability of these fine
muscles to focus is not as easy as when one was younger. This is why older people
have to hold things at a distance to see clearly or use lens or glasses to make
that correction. So in dealing with people beyond 35 or 40 years of age who are
taking reading courses, the chances that they have progressive difficulty in focusing
is a problem to be reckoned with.
Vision is a learned process. For example, we learn to move our eyes for a maximum
of visual efficiency according to the visual task. Secondly, when the data from
the optic nerves reach the brain, it is interpreted through our entire past experiences
and visual reactions that we have previously made to like situations or like stimulations
For example, take two persons, one who can read and one who cannot read and have
them look at a printed word. Now first of all the non-reader has not learned visual-motor
attack techniques. He may not know, for example, that his eyes should move from
left to right. He does not know what part of the word he is to look at to make
the best visual discrimination. In fact he may move his whole head as he scans
back and forth because he has never learned the fine muscle movements needed for
a close exacting task like reading. Now both the reader and non-reader would receive
visual impulses to the brain from the word. But the reader's visual impulses will
be orderly, organized and structured for immediate interpretation in the brain.
This is a learned process. He look at the front part, he knows that some parts
of words are more suggestive to the meaning or the pronunciation of the word,
so the eye seeks for these clues. It is a learned task-a technical task which
a person who does not know how to read does not know. The non-reader will be haphazard
and disorganized. Even if he knows the letters of the alphabet he may not know
the rules of visual combination based on common sound units. A person who does
not read may have good vision, but he does not know how to use his eyes, he will
not have been taught to operate in a directed logical way to figure out what the
word says.
For the one who can read, however, the eye muscles steer the eye through a learned
pattern of responses which select light energy from an object like a printed word.
This light energy transformed into electro-mechanical impulses is finally perceived
in the brain as a decoded word The perceptual area in he brain for the one who
can read is prepared by many such previous experiences so that immediate visual
memory takes over and decoding is accomplished. In other words, there has been
a lot of previous preparation for a person who can use his eyes adequately for
recognition of words.
Final conscious awareness of what is seen is more than the sum of the parts of
vision taken separately. This is important, because working to correct one part
of the system will not necessarily assume correction of the entire system. Neither
does an observed problem in a part of the system necessarily mean that acceptable
visual data for processing cannot be received by the brain.
The research shows that there is a small relationship between vision and reading,
(not a high relationship). Yet, in a broader sense, vision is the key to a person's
whole development including general school achievement. Personality, posture and
adjustment to life are closely related to visual development. Experiments at Purdue
University indicate that posture problems developed through faulty vision are
retained throughout life. Spinal curvature, head tilts, unequal shoulder heights
can be traced to uncorrected visual problems in the classroom. Behaviour is the
most important clue to visual difficulties and various behavioral symptoms will
be discussed later.
If we think about the whole cycle of vision it seems possible that a highly organized
ad well-programmed brain could indeed create conscious perceptual experience from
less than an ideal sensory input. This reasoning also suggests that trying to
find out a single cause for a reading failure such as a visual sensory defect
is seldom realistic. While learning, the disabled students may need visual correction.
But it does not necessarily follow that his learning will automatically improve
or that his learning difficulty was casually related to his visual problem, e.g.,
a person may have relatively poor visual acuity which is the product of the sensory
mechanism and he may even have poor muscular control. Yet the perceptual area
may be so highly and richly programmed by earlier experiences that his reading
will be adequate.
We cannot learn much from books if we have not had any earlier experiences relating
to the subject. If the teacher gives an assignment and asks the students to learn
a particular thing without any experiences other than those out of the textbook,
the mind is not collating or filling away experiences to which he can relate this
reading and thus very little is learnt. Even in the learning of languages, just
a learning of a language of a book is a very poor way of doing it. One has to
have experience with the language; the brain has to have a lot of experiences
in order to finally come around to say that is what this is and that is what you
are seeing. As was said earlier, perception is related to the sound, smell and
touch of things that has been sensed in real experience. Reading is simply recalling
these memories through the visual use of symbols. This idea of forming perceptions
is related to the idea of forming concepts. Concepts cannot be formed except through
a great many varied ways of approach to the same area of knowledge, e.g., if all
that a person does is to get information from a book, this concept of the idea
is extremely narrow and he will never know much about that area, although he may
be able to quote the book backwards and forwards. It is more than book learning,
it is more than rote learning. It would be more useful to teach only half of the
amount this way compared to rote learning. It is better to have direct experiences
of a thing, than to only read about all kinds of experiences.
Now let us look back to the Sensory Process to the thing we call vision. Several
conditions may interfere with it. For example, there may be a blurring condition.
There may be a muscular condition. These can obviously interfere with the ability
to read. There are symptoms which are observable with these conditions. For example,
if you see someone who excessively rubs his eyes, a person who frowns when he
reads, who seems to want to rub away a blur, avoid close work, who blinks a great
deal, who may stumble over small objects, who holds small objects close in order
to see them or who may be sensitive to light, etc., a vision problem may be indicated.
If three or four of these kinds of symptoms seem to be present, then there may
be a visual problem and this person should be examined by a vision specialist.
The main point in terms of perception and vision in reading is that one can have
a very god mechanical, optical system, and still be a poor reader because the
perceptual system in the brain has not been richly endowed with ideas from other
sources. On the contrary, one may have a poor optical system from a sensory point
of view and be a good reader because he may have a very highly enriched perceptual
system which has been built up through a great many experiences. The best and
the ideal system, of course, is good eyes and a good mind. Vision is important
but the build up of information through other ways is as important to the reading
act as is good vision.
Lighting
and Vision
Good lighting is important to good vision. Light is measured by foot-candles.
It is suggested that about 70 foot-candles of light is required in a room. Poor
lighting causes discomfort. It can cause visual strain. But it does not injure
the eyes. Too little light cannot hurt the eye, but too much can hurt it.
Try
to keep a proper light level. Do not get the room too dark. Have the light come
over the shoulder preferably rather than having students facing a window.
Summary
While vision is important for reading, all kinds of experiences are also important
to build up concepts so that reading can be meaningful and a minimal number of
clues for reading can bring ideas to the readers' mind. So if the reader has either
good or poor vision, the best way to use that vision in the best possible way
is to build up perceptions other than through reading by many other ways.
Vision is very important, but the eye in itself cannot create meaning from the
printed page. Meaning has to come through the touch, the taste, the feeling, the
attitude, the talking about all kinds of experiences that can be fed into the
brain mechanism if reading can really work.
The
teacher has a role in vision by remembering that-
1.
While vision is important for reading all kinds of experiences are also important
to buildup a concept formation. So that the reading can be meaningful and a minimal
number of clues for reading will bring ideas to the reader's mind because he has
had an enrichment of ideas through other sources besides reading. So if a person
has good or poor vision, the best way to use that vision to the best possible
way is to build up perceptions other than through the reading act, through many
other ways of teaching.
2. If there seems to be any students who
have problems with vision that should be attended to, parents should be informed
about it so that they can take him to an eye specialist.
3. Try
to keep a proper light level. Do not keep the room too dark. Have the light come
over the shoulder preferably rather than having students face a window.